Turns out I got both guys. First guy (Karl Pope):
Jump Shot: average	 Jump Range: average
Outside Def.: respectable	 Handling: average
Driving: inept	 Passing: inept
Inside Shot: atrocious	 Inside Def.: awful
Rebounding: inept	 Shot Blocking: inept
Stamina: mediocre	 Free Throw: strong
 	  
Experience: atrocious
Second guy (Kirby Thomas):
Jump Shot: inept	 Jump Range: respectable
Outside Def.: average	 Handling: respectable
Driving: awful	 Passing: respectable
Inside Shot: awful	 Inside Def.: respectable
Rebounding: atrocious	 Shot Blocking: average
Stamina: average	 Free Throw: pitiful
 	  
Experience: atrocious
I think I did it for the first guy, for the second guy I was off. So overall, I guess I'd say box score can be sort of reliable, but not something to totally depend upon.