I think that's a pretty fair assessment. I do expect my teams to always out perform their salaries, in addition to having the strongest bench in the league by a fair margin (probably too much, to be honest). But I started the season thinking I was somewhere 3-5 in the Big 8, so I'm not disappointed by being considered 5th overall. I will point out that I'm 3-0 against the other teams listed. Decent odds I'll be 3-3 by the end of the season though.
I don't really concern myself too much with my league record against teams from the other conference. For example, I don't know how often either of us really cared or tried to win our game. I'm sure there were instances when both of us may have essentially treated it as the scrimmage game for that week due to the other match-ups if we were still in the cup. And other than this season, we both have generally done fairly well in the cup. Based on that, I'm not certain how a game where both of us were trying would really go, although I'd pick you as the favorite to win a three game series.
I really should have bought a couple of bigs the year Valhalla! won the league. But I'm pretty sure I would have been an instant demotee and that really isn't my approach. I'm fine with slow and steady improvements. Although that was by far the weakest season the league has had since I arrived. Also can't say I'm too surprised he was gone from the game in less than two seasons after that.
And I understand completely about not wanting to part with Joe. Ted Eller was one of my original players and he will be on my team until his skills have degraded to all atrocious. In fact, I never trained him to his full potential because I wouldn't have been able to keep him if I had. Many may not agree with that approach, but I get more enjoyment out of the fact that he has played over 250 league games for me than I would from having trained him up and then selling him for a large sum. My next goal for him is trying to find a game where I can get him the team record for assists. Although the last time I tried that, he ended up setting the team record for points instead.