Ok,  I'll join in with my 2 cents.  Everyone will be from  the mid 80's on,  because of my age group and who I've actually see play.
JS:  Larry Bird -  I've seen a lot of people post MJ here,  but watch some youtube clips of Bird.
JR:  Reggie Miller
OD:  Gary Payton - "The Glove" 
HA:  John Stockton
PA:  Magic - flashier than Stockton.
DR:  Jordan - Once again,  watch some youtube clips,  I know LeBron is a popular pick here,  but when Jordan wanted to go   to  the basket,  he went.  LeBron is still not at that level.
ID:  Hakeem Olajouwon (I'm sure I spelled that wrong)
RB:  Dennis Rodman
IS:  Kevin McHale / Kareem -  while Shaq dominated on pure size and strength,  Kareem's sky hook was a thing of beauty,  and no one,  I mean no one i've ever seen had more wierd,  screwy post up moves than McHale.
SB:  Hakeem again
FS:  Larry Bird 
ST:  Isiah Thomas 
Exp:  Jordan / Kareem & Robert Parish  - the game appears to give weight in experience to playoffs - hence Jordan.  For pure games played,  Kareem and Parish who booth played into there 40's.